• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Your Pizza Shop - Wooster | Authentic, Flavorful Pizza & Friendly Local Service

Your Pizza Shop - Wooster, located at 503 E Liberty St, is a classic neighborhood pizzeria known for its warm service and flavorful offerings. Customers rave about their rich, well-seasoned sauce, generous pepperoni pizza, and satisfying sides like jojos, wings, and meatball subs. The unpretentious, family-friendly atmosphere and quick service make it a beloved spot for locals and travelers alike. Open even on Sundays, they go beyond expectations with thoughtful touches like delivery to nearby locations. Its cozy interior and consistently delicious dishes create a welcoming space that feels like home, making it a must-visit for authentic, hearty pizza in Wooster.

Your Pizza Shop - Wooster at a glance

  • Address 503 E Liberty St, Wooster, OH 44691, United States
  • Phone +1 330-804-0404
  • Restaurant type Pizza takeaway .
  • Popular for Dinner , Solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Your Pizza Shop - Wooster: Reviews & Ratings

Amanda Kephart
5

Excellent pizza and service! They are open on Sundays, which is a rare thing in Wooster, and we were watching the Browns game at JAFB. My husband walked over to Your Pizza, which is a 1 min walk from JAFB, ordered and paid, and when it was ready they were kind enough to deliver the pizza to us at JAFB (even though my husband said he’d come back and get it). It was very nice of them and the pepperoni pizza was full of flavor!

Heather Crose
5

We like to drive and get lost from Mansfield. Somewhere in between we also love to stop and visit a restaurant or diner we've never been! We stopped just inside Wooster to Your Pizza and they did not disappoint! We were given a coupon, so we got a two topping pizza, jojos, and two brownies! The inside of the pizza shop is beautiful and has a few tables for eating at. However, we grabbed some paper plates and drove a couple roads over to a park to eat. A mini date. Empty nesting is so weird. :) The pizza was amazing! The jojos were amazing and the brownies were so delicious! Thank you for making our little date night so good!

Jamie Blake
5

Old-school neighborhood pizza shop with a super sweet staff. Family friendly, and exactly what you’d expect in terms of food: hot, relatively quick, reasonably priced, tastes good. This is your regular folks pizzeria, not a fancy overpriced bistro. It’s pretty unassuming from the outside but it hits the spot, and the great people make the place. We’ll definitely come back again!

Liz Bogucki
5

We did take out from here for the first time. I knew from my phone call placing the order that this was going to be a good experience. They were very friendly on the phone. We ordered a pizza, meatball sub, wings, and mushrooms. The sauce they use is incredible. Lots of flavor. The wings were huge and the mushrooms were very flavorful. The meatball sub was also great. 10/10 highly recommend going back.

Location

  • Your Pizza Shop - Wooster
    Your Pizza Shop - Wooster
    503 E Liberty St, Wooster, OH 44691, United States Hotline: +1 330-804-0404

Located just a minute’s walk from JAFB at 503 E Liberty St in Wooster, Your Pizza Shop - Wooster stands out as a warm, old-school neighborhood pizzeria where genuine hospitality meets satisfying flavors. This unpretentious spot serves classic, flavorful pizza that feels like home—highlighted by a rich, well-balanced sauce and generous toppings, especially their pepperoni that bursts with savory goodness. The staff's kindness and attentiveness shine through, exemplified by their thoughtful delivery of a fresh pizza right to customers at JAFB during a Browns game, proving their commitment to excellent service.

Beyond pizza, their menu offers a delightful variety—crispy, sizable wings, hearty meatball subs with robust flavor, and perfectly seasoned mushrooms add depth to the meal. The inclusion of tasty sides like jojos and rich, fudgy brownies makes Your Pizza Shop a full-flavored experience that's both satisfying and comforting. The charming interior—with cozy seating—invites families and friends to gather, though many choose to enjoy their feast at nearby parks, turning each visit into a memorable mini getaway.

Your Pizza Shop is not about fancy presentations but about delivering reliably good food, reasonably priced, and served by staff who truly care. This balance of simplicity, warmth, and quality makes it a standout pit stop for locals and travelers craving genuine, hearty pizza fare in Wooster. Whether you’re seeking a quick slice or a full meal with traditional sides, this shop consistently hits the spot, making every visit feel like coming home to a beloved classic.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • On-site services
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Credit cards
    • Debit cards
    • Credit cards